Yellowtail Inn

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

You would think a small family owned property would at least carry amazing customer service for such a poorly maintained property. I was cursed out by the front desk manager, "Christian" for calling t ... more on TripAdvisor

I agree with the stay in your car sentiment. Smelled so strong of lysol or something that we had to keep patio doors wide open to air out. Looked dirty; didn't want to touch anything. Swimming pool th ... more on TripAdvisor

It's a great value-priced property. If you are looking for deluxe 5 star accomodations, you're not going to find it the Keys for $129/night! YT has a few cottages on a white sand beach, with tables an ... more on TripAdvisor

We stayed in a free standing cottage right on beach. Staff was helpul and friendly, cottage was clean and comfortable. Pool next door was bigger so we used that one. Lots of beach . Flats were great t ... more on TripAdvisor

Arrival quite a shock. Grumpy guy at front desk who seems rather resentful of your business and would definitely not recommend us anything in the area. Sheets stained and pillows covered in hairs from ... more on TripAdvisor