Scribner Hollow Lodge

Rte 23A, Hunter, Catskills, NY 12442

4.0

User Rating (3 sources) ×

Yahoo! Travel
TravelPost.com
TripAdvisor

Congratulations!

You have one of the Best of Uptake awards.

If you would like to include this award badge on your website, copy and paste the code below.

Size: 154 x 38

TripAdvisor

Scribner Hollow has the ambiance of a classic mountain lodge, with award winning accommodations, ... more on TripAdvisor

Check rates is unavailable for this property

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

3 sources ×

Yahoo! Travel
TravelPost.com
TripAdvisor

26 reviews

4.0

User Rating

Our Take

Ratings & Reviews for Scribner Hollow Lodge from Around the Web

Avg Rating

4.0

26 reviews

66% of guests recommend this place.

Comfort:

Condition & Cleanliness:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

That has to say something about the type of place that Scribner Hollow REALLY is...and I'm sure that Wine Spectator Magazine wouldn't give the award of excellence 6 years in a row for nothing! more on Yahoo! Travel

The staff was very friendly and helpful. more on TripAdvisor

The staff was very courteous and eager to please. more on Yahoo! Travel

We could drop our stuff at the room, which was cleaned but still cold, but would be nice and warm when we came back, they said. more on TripAdvisor

The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

The hotel was awful, the pool is in a dark unfinished basement with old and dirty green rugs. The price was expensive. ... more on TripAdvisor

Last year, when I was six months pregnant, my husband and I paid our first visit to Scribner Hollow Lodge. It had been referred to us by a friend who knew we were looking for a place to celebrate my b ... more on TripAdvisor

I had the pleasure of visiting Scribner Hollow Lodge this past weekend and must share my positive experience. I stayed at the hotel with my husband and two children for two nights over the weekend and ... more on TripAdvisor

I've stayed at Marriot, Hyatt and Hilton Hotels. I've also stayed at the Peninsula Hotel in Chicago, The Mandarin Oriental in NY City, the Palazzo in Las Vegas and The Shore Club in Miami, Fl.... It's ... more on TripAdvisor

Summary: Worst bed ever. Cold room. Wet carpet. Housekeeping only changes towels. Full review: Last year we stayed in Scribner Hollow. We had no other choice than to ignore the bad reviews as there we ... more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

4.5

15 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

Having run across this website I noticed the reviews for the Lodge. I stayed there last summer (2004). WHAT A DUMP!! I have to agree with ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Just returned from Scribner's Hollow Lodge on hunter Mountain. DO NOT STAY HERE!! This is one on the most mis-represented hotels I have ever stayed at. In fact it was so bad, we didn't even stay. BE WARNED, after you book your reservation, ... more on Yahoo! Travel

The lodge is charming, the food is fresh,good. The grotto pool is great after skiing-the mt is so close. The only negative is that it ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Two weeks ago, on a whim, a dear friend and I went looking for place to unwind and have fun. From the moment we arrived at Scribner Hollow Lodge, we were welcomed like family. Before even unloading the car, we were invited to the ... more on Yahoo! Travel

We recently stayed at this wonderful ski lodge. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable. The restaurant is lovely and the food delicious. They have an extensive wine list of unique wines from all over the world. Our room was great. ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

6.0

Top Reviews From TravelPost.com

Bad service, bad food---why bother?The meat was tough and over cooked. First they brought me a bad bottle of wine, next they brought ... more on TravelPost.com