Montauk Lake Club & Marina

211 East Lake Drive Montauk,NY 11954

Hotel Class

3.0

User Rating (5 sources) ×

TripAdvisor
Yahoo! Travel
Travelocity.com
TravelPost.com
CitySearch

Nestled midway down the protected eastern shore of Montauk's safe harbor, the Montauk Lake Club was built in 1930 during the Carl Fisher era as part of the Montauk Dream plan of creating a playground for the rich and famous. The ... more on Montauknyguide.com

Check Rates & Availability:

Check In
Check Out
# Guests
Montauk Lake Club & MarinaGet Rates

Finding partner sites with pricing and availability
information for this hotel...

Estimated Price: From $165

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

Ratings & Reviews for Montauk Lake Club & Marina from Around the Web

Avg Rating

19 reviews

71% of guests recommend this place.

Comfort:

Condition & Cleanliness:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

Lovely place--spotless, great staff, very comfortable place to stay with our dog. more on Travelocity.com

BTW, a great place to eat in the area was called: Gosman's Restaurant. more on Yahoo! Travel

Find comprehensive hotel information including descriptions, rates & availability, photos, reviews and interactive maps for Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina in Montauk, New York. more on Yahoo! Travel

The indoor pool was deep and refreshing. more on Yahoo! Travel

We Are A 107 Room Hotel And We Offer 2 Outdoor Swimming Pools In The Summer Months Only And 1 Indoors Heated Swimming Pool Available... more on Hotels.com

Avg Rating

4 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

We booked the Montauk Yacht Club for a wedding reception. We had called 3 weeks earlier to ask re: early check-in and were told that it would be ok; however, when we arrived early we were told that it could not be accomodated. We ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Spent the night there last Octiber, on a sunday night. The staff at the front desk was smart, and helpful. The huge room overlooked the bay/lake with a large deck. On the beach below, in the marshes was a huge nasty duck, who refused ... more on Yahoo! Travel

The Montauk Yacht Club is certainly a nice hotel (probably the 2nd nicest behind Guerneys), but I think if you visit Montauk, you should stay on or near the beach! This hotel is located on Lake Montauk, close to the harbor. It's ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Our vacation to the Montauk Yacht Club was an absolute terrable experience. In fact, we stayed one night and then left (our stay was initially intended for 4 nights). The person who designed the website deserves a prise for fooling ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Find comprehensive hotel information including descriptions, rates & availability, photos, reviews and interactive maps for Montauk Yacht ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

While the location can't be beat I think the management of this property needs to fine tune quite a few things. We rented three rooms and two were lovely; one was in the "cottage" and looked like an a ... more on TripAdvisor

Our family was there for Columbus Day Weekend. Though the beacheswere closed, we had a blast. The resort... more on TripAdvisor

My wife and two young children stayed here for three nights during our first visit to Montauk. Montauk and the east end of Long Island is not anywhere near as nice as the beaches in New England. This ... more on TripAdvisor

I live on long island so I booked a two night stay mid-week on an internet site to stay in montauk. Big... more on TripAdvisor

Stayed at the hotel during their slow season and was very, very disappointed. Restaurant was only open for breakfast, after that you could not even get a coffee, no alternatives were offered for lunch ... more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

2 reviews

See Reviews From:

Top Reviews From TravelPost.com

My husband and I took a quick getaway trip to Montauk during the week. We searched and finally found Montauk Yacht Club Resort and Marina, one of the few hotels that would accept one night of stay (most hotels near Montauk will not ... more on TravelPost.com