»

Clegg's Hotel

478 Bayberry Walk, Fire Island, Long Island, New York

3.5

User Rating (2 sources) ×

CitySearch
TripAdvisor

The Scene :Location, location, location. This hotel boasts one of the best, just a stumble from the ferry, 100 feet from the bay and smack in the midst of the bars, restaurants, and shops on Bay Walk. This friendly establishment was ... more on CitySearch

Check rates is unavailable for this property

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

2 sources ×

CitySearch
TripAdvisor

11 reviews

3.5

User Rating

Our Take

Ratings & Reviews for Clegg's Hotel from Around the Web

Avg Rating

3.5

11 reviews

66% of guests recommend this place.

Comfort:

Condition & Cleanliness:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

Price of your stay is average for the town and cheap considering your facing the bay. more on CitySearch

If you go, find a bed and breakfast or rent a cottage with some friends. more on TripAdvisor

Would I stay here again? more on CitySearch

Try eating at Housers, excellent food and service. more on TripAdvisor

The hotel's decor is simple and clean. more on CitySearch

Avg Rating

8 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

The hotel is in Ocean Beach right beside the ferry and is advertised as rustic, right on the water. In reality, it is a dump. We booked a suite ($239 US) with a kitchenette and bathroom, as there were ... more on TripAdvisor

We made reservsations to stay at Clegg's Hotel on 7/21 - 7/22/06. My credit card was charged 1-night deposit of $175.20 to guarantee the reservation. On 7/20 a tropical storm watch was issued for Fire ... more on TripAdvisor

When arriving the room was very disappointing. On first look we assumed it had not been cleaned properly. Talking to the manager about the cleanliness of a room was not a nice thing to do on vacaton, ... more on TripAdvisor

AVOID this place at all cost ! It's FALSE REPRESENTATION. It's dirty, unfriendly, noisy, ugly, insanely overpriced, paint pealing off the walls, no outside view, cheap sugar breakfast, insane 50% nonr ... more on TripAdvisor

I'm not sure we stayed at the same place as all these other (negative) reviewers. I found them when I logged on to reserve our rooms at Clegg's for this summer, and I can't believe them! Whenever my f ... more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

4.5

3 reviews

Top Reviews From CitySearch

Clegg's Hotel is a located in the center of Ocean Beach Fire Island. The hotel's decor is simple and clean. We stayed at other hotels and recommend that you choose Clegg's. Price of your stay is average for the town and cheap considering ... more on CitySearch

This place is a decent place to stay provided the weather is nice and you don't need or wish to be inside; the accommodations are akin to what you would find in an aged college dorm room. The beds are adequate; the dressers are adequate; ... more on CitySearch

I stayed at Clegg's with my son for 4 days and the room had mosquitoes in it, a big gash/hole under the sink about a foot wide and long--I was afraid of what might come out of the hole at night, the room had holes on the walls and ... more on CitySearch