American Hotel

Main Street, Sag Harbor,NY 11963

Hotel Class

3.5

User Rating (3 sources) ×

Yahoo! Travel
TripAdvisor
TravelPost.com

Congratulations!

You have one of the Best of Uptake awards.

If you would like to include this award badge on your website, copy and paste the code below.

Size: 154 x 38

TripAdvisor

Description :1800's inn - Located on Main St.;Professional Review :In this once historic, now artsy, town known formerly for whaling, sits a brick Gothic Revival building dating from 1846. Once a whaler's inn, this is a clubby, idiosyncratic ... more on ProfessionalTravelGuide.com

Check rates is unavailable for this property

Read Reviews

View Map & Directions

3 sources ×

TravelPost.com
TripAdvisor
Yahoo! Travel

14 reviews

3.5

User Rating

Our Take

Ratings & Reviews for American Hotel from Around the Web

Avg Rating

14 reviews

100% of guests recommend this place.

Comfort:

Condition & Cleanliness:

Service & Staff:

Value:

Top Reviews from Around the Web:

The place has an unbelievable wine list and Vinnie makes a mean cocktail. more on Yahoo! Travel

I don't know who is cooking now but food was as good as it always was. more on Yahoo! Travel

The food was wonderful. more on TripAdvisor

Aside from this incident, the food and service was fine. more on Yahoo! Travel

White glove service and French food: Been to this restaurant many times most recently last weekend. more on Yahoo! Travel

Avg Rating

10 reviews

Top Reviews From TripAdvisor

We went there with our daughters for MLK WE with our daughters and took two rooms. Nice and cozzy rools at a not too expensive ... more on TripAdvisor

If you're hoping a stay at the American Hotel will be a nice, quiet getaway out of NYC, think again. This place is louder than my apartment in Manhattan. There was incessant door slamming (yes, slammi ... more on TripAdvisor

My husband and I were just driving around Long Island and after finding a B&B in the Hamptons that was $295 a night, we drove over to Sag Harbor and saw the American Hotel. Booked a night for $175, (I ... more on TripAdvisor

I've been here twice this summer, with and without children. It is a great place if you like your comforts and don't mind that they come wrapped in antique format. The rooms are surprisingly comfortab ... more on TripAdvisor

You can just feel the cultural ambience in the American Hotel, that's what I love about this place. The number of artists over the years who have lived upstairs and then ate/drank/wrote downstairs. It ... more on TripAdvisor

Avg Rating

4 reviews

Top Reviews From Yahoo! Travel

Been to this restaurant many times, most recently last weekend. Service was excellent. Setting is unique and inviting and on beautiful Sag Harbor main street. A place to be and a place to be seen. Not any more expensive than any other ... more on Yahoo! Travel

high prices but reliable great food in a romantic setting, with friendly waiters who always remember you (one dug me out of a snowbank two winters ago, after stopping and seeing my car had skidded off a ... more on Yahoo! Travel

I went for dinner with three men, all of us Asian and dressed in casual attire, but the manager warmly informed my party to "come back before noon tomorrow to apply for a job." I replied, "we'll come back tomorrow, can we have dinner ... more on Yahoo! Travel

Perhaps we have higher expectations of food coming from Manhattan. But as Sag Harbor and the surrounding "villages" are an outpost of the wealthier set, we expected far better than we received at the American Hotel. After ordering ... more on Yahoo! Travel

See Reviews From:

Top Reviews From igougo

This Bed and Breakfast's restaurant is supposed to be one of the area's best. I have to let you know that this is COMPLETELY FALSE! ... more on igougo