The American Hotel - Sag Harbor Hotel

Class:

4.0 stars
per ProfessionalTravelGuide.com
Address: 25 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone: +1 631 725 3535
Website:www.theamericanhotel.com

Average Rating	3.5	10+ reviews from 2 sources
Yahoo! Travel	4.5	4+ reviews
TripAdvisor	3.0	6+ reviews

Estimated Price: From $175

The American Hotel

25 Main St
Sag Harbor, NY 11963

The American Hotel Details

We Recommend The American Hotel Because

"we ll come back tomorrow, can we have dinner now because we were only there to have a nice dinner" more on Yahoo! Travel
"think that tells you alot about the quality of the restaurant and its clientele" more on TripAdvisor
"place has an unbelievable wine list and vinnie makes a mean cocktail" more on Yahoo! Travel
"had heard that the american hotel was a lovely place to stay" more on TripAdvisor
"was excellent. Setting is unique and inviting and on beautiful sag harbor main street" more on Yahoo! Travel

Full Amenity List

Cable/satellite televsion
Television
Maid service
Air conditioning
telephone
minibar
bath tub with spray jets
non-smoking
Non-smoking rooms
Lounge/bar
Minibar
Restaurant
room service

Descriptions from Across the Web

1800's inn - Located ... more on Yahoo! Travel
... :1800's inn - Located on Main St.;Professional Review :In this once historic, now artsy, town known formerly for whaling, sits a brick Gothic Revival building dating from 1846. Once a whaler's inn, this is a clubby, idiosyncratic institution, ... more on ProfessionalTravelGuide.com
Victorian elegance defines this hotel dating from 1846. The three-story brick facade and white-pillared porch look out on Main Street. ... more on Fodor's
1800's inn - Located ... more on TripAdvisor

Reviews From Across The Web read all

4.0

White glove service and French food

(09/22/06)

... many times, most recently last weekend. Service was excellent. Setting is unique and inviting and on beautiful Sag Harbor main street. A place to be and a place to be seen. Not any more expensive than any other restaurant in the Hamptons. ... By A Yahoo! User, a user of Yahoo! Travel. Read full review on Yahoo! Travel

5.0

Great food in a cozy setting, especially in the winter when a fire blazes in the bar dining room.

(11/09/06)

... but reliable great food in a romantic setting, with friendly waiters who always remember you (one dug me out of a snowbank two winters ago, after stopping and seeing my car had skidded off a deserted country ... By A Yahoo! User from Sag harbor, NY, a user of Yahoo! Travel. Read full review on Yahoo! Travel

4.0

Warm welcome?

(04/24/06)

... for dinner with three men, all of us Asian and dressed in casual attire, but the manager warmly informed my party to "come back before noon tomorrow to apply for a job." I replied, "we'll come back tomorrow, can we have dinner now?" ... By A Yahoo! User, a user of Yahoo! Travel. Read full review on Yahoo! Travel

1.0

American Hotel Restaurant

(10/08/04)

... expectations of food coming from Manhattan. But as Sag Harbor and the surrounding "villages" are an outpost of the wealthier set, we expected far better than we received at the American Hotel. After ordering a salad for starters, ... By A Yahoo! Traveler, a user of Yahoo! Travel. Read full review on Yahoo! Travel

Sag Harbor's Finest

(Oct 4, 2006)

... perfect, but it's been a favorite for several years and truly deserves its reputation as one of the finest dining establishments on the East End. Try the crab salad sandwiches, brandade de morue, the petite filet, the duck, ....I could ... MarlymyTonk, a user of tripadvisor.com. Read full review on TripAdvisor