Shelter Island Hotels - Reviews of Hotels in Shelter Island NY
35 accommodations found from 5,000 sites
ACandle Lite Inn & Guest House
| Average Rating |
4.5
|
1+ reviews from 2 sources |
|---|---|---|
| Yahoo! Travel | 5.0 |
1+ reviews |
| CitySearch | 3.5 |
0+ reviews |
- great grounds, amazing breakfast, carol and callie were a complete delight to wake up and have breakfast with, friendly and acco more on Yahoo! Travel
- ... Beautiful old Home, great grounds, amazing breakfast, Carol and Callie were a complete delight to wake up and have breakfast with, friendly and accommodating. ... more on Yahoo! Travel
Candle Lite Inn & Guest House
3 S Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964
BThe Pridwin
| Average Rating |
3.0
|
29+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| TripAdvisor | 3.0 |
29+ reviews |
- beautiful setting and food was excellent ; room was adequate and service great ; very accommodating--staff anxious to please ; r more on TripAdvisor
- great view & relaxation more on TripAdvisor
Estimated Price: From $169
The Pridwin
P.O. Box 2009Crescent Beach, Shelter Island, NY 11965
CDering Harbor Inn
| Average Rating |
4.5
|
1+ reviews from 2 sources |
|---|---|---|
| CitySearch | 3.5 |
0+ reviews |
| Yahoo! Travel | 5.0 |
1+ reviews |
- Highlights: maid service, restaurant, non-smoking… more
- ... view like the one at Dering Harbor, you don't need anything else. But wait, there's more: tennis courts, basketball net, badmiton nets, picnic area, and a pool too! Don't go for the rooms, whic... more on Yahoo! Travel
- Overview Lodge style, 7-acre site directly on Dering Harbor ... more on Yahoo! Travel
Estimated Price: From $170
Dering Harbor Inn
13 Winthrop RdShelter Island, NY 11964
DPridwin Hotel & Cottages
| Average Rating |
4.5
|
2+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| Yahoo! Travel | 4.5 |
2+ reviews |
- Highlights: pool, restaurant, kitchen, refrigerator more
- cottage we stayed at was lovely and the area of the hotel is both relaxing and rejuvenating more on Yahoo! Travel
- cottage we stayed at was lovely and the area of the hotel is both relaxing and rejuvenating more on Yahoo! Travel
Pridwin Hotel & Cottages
Crescent BeachShore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
ERam's Head Inn
| Average Rating |
3.5
|
6+ reviews from 3 sources |
|---|---|---|
| CitySearch | 3.5 |
0+ reviews |
| TripAdvisor | 3.5 |
3+ reviews |
| Yelp | 3.5 |
3+ reviews |
- Highlights: restaurant more
- atmosphere is perfect. more on Yelp
- our room was bright and comfortable more on TripAdvisor
Estimated Price: From $237
Ram's Head Inn
108 Rams Island DrShelter Island, NY 11965
FCandlelite Inn
| Average Rating |
3.0
|
2+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| TripAdvisor | 3.0 |
2+ reviews |
- ... the private back cottage for our anniversary last October. Upon ariving (Friday) we walked in to a hair salon (main floor of the B & B) and were given a key to the back cottage. The room was ni... more on TripAdvisor
- ... and I arrived at the Candlelight Inn on a Sunday afternoon in June 06 .The owners were not in but we found a "welcome" letter taped to the door.The portion of the letter that listed the contine... more on TripAdvisor
Candlelite Inn
Route 114 SouthShelter Island, NY
GShelter Island Hideaway
| Average Rating |
5.0
|
1+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| Yelp | 5.0 |
1+ reviews |
- Your search for paradise has ended", July 14, 2008 more on Yelp
Shelter Island Hideaway
1 Brander ParkwayShelter Island,NY,11964
HPridwin
| Average Rating |
2.5
|
2+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| Fodor's | 2.5 |
2+ reviews |
- Highlights: pool, restaurant, kitchen, refrigerator more
- m impressed with the value as compared with other shelter island places, especially if you go for the plan that includes dinner more on Fodor's
- Loud music until after midnight, the place is run down and the staff is not very friendly more on Fodor's
Pridwin
Shore Rd.Shelter Island, NY, 11964
IFour West Neck
| Average Rating |
3.0
|
1+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| TripAdvisor | 3.0 |
1+ reviews |
- two bedrooms where guests stay are right next to one another so you can hear other people talk more on TripAdvisor
- it! gross! there is a nice patio attached to the rooms and a beautiful garden more on TripAdvisor
Estimated Price: From $200
Four West Neck
4 West Neck RoadShelter Island, NY
JSunset Beach
| Average Rating |
3.5
|
8+ reviews from 2 sources |
|---|---|---|
| Tablet Hotels | 14.5 |
8+ reviews |
| CitySearch | 3.5 |
0+ reviews |
- Highlights: restaurant, kitchen, kitchen more
- least food was good open air setting extremely luxurious. more on Tablet Hotels
- need to attend to basic things esp for the price. Restaurant really great though outrageously priced. more on Tablet Hotels
Sunset Beach
35 Shore Rd.Shelter Island, NY, 11965
