Page 2 of Hotels in Shelter Island, New York

#11.

Olde Country Inn

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, Long Island, New York

Olde Country Inn
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • Food was uninspirering & staff was overwhelmed. Would not go back. more on TripAdvisor
  • As a recent West Coast transplant, I was seeking a weekend getaway from NYC, to relax and recharge, La Mais... more on TripAdvisor
 

See_details_btn

#12.

Ram's Head Inn

Ram's Island Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY

Ram's Head Inn
 

See_details_btn

#13.

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, Long Island, NY 11965

Sunset Beach
3.0
User Rating (2 sources) ×
 

See_details_btn

#14.

Chequit Inn

23 Grand Ave., Shelter Island, Long Island, New York

Chequit Inn
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×
 

See_details_btn

#15.

The Greenporter Hotel and Spa

326 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

The Greenporter Hotel and Spa
3.5
User Rating (3 sources) ×
  • Food was GREAT! more on CitySearch
  • A $5 million renovation has created a clever tribute to Mid-Century Modern style--and a fresh alternative t... more on TravelAndLeisure.com
 

#16.

Harborfront Inn at Greenport

209 Front St, Greenport, North Fork, Long Island, New York

Harborfront Inn at Greenport
3.0
User Rating (2 sources) ×
 

See_details_btn

#17.

The Greenporter

326 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

The Greenporter
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • trying to cancel my trip due to a newly diagnosed terminal illness in the family. Instead of honoring the p... more on TripAdvisor
  • My husband and I, along with three other couples stayed at The Greenporter Hotel this past New Year's Eve. ... more on TripAdvisor
 

See_details_btn

#18.

Association for The Help of Retarded Children Inc

222 3rd St, Greenport, NY 11944

Association for The Help of Retarded Children Inc
 

See_details_btn

#19.

Lemon Tree Inn

250 9TH Street South

Lemon Tree Inn
Hotel Class
5.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • VirtualTourist
  • Lots of good restaurants within a few blocks and TWO Starbucks within 3 blocks, not to mention another grea... more on VirtualTourist
  • Much better than the $79 rate we paid, it was a 4 star hotel with 2 star prices . more on VirtualTourist
 

See_details_btn

#20.

Holiday Inn RUTLAND-KILLINGTON AREA

476 US Rt 7 South

Holiday Inn RUTLAND-KILLINGTON AREA
Hotel Class
 

See_details_btn

Shelter Island Lodging

Shelter Island Things To Do

Shelter Island Nightlife

New York Resources

© 2006 - 2012 Uptake Networks, Inc.

Uptake

Get the best tips and advice by discovering which of your friends have been to Shelter Island, and also reach our helpful and experienced Uptake travel community. Sign in!

×
Uptake

Did you know that your Internet Explorer is out of date?


To get the best possible experience using our website we recommend that you upgrade to a newer version.

Close