Kid Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island NY - Family Hotel Reviews

31 accommodations found from 5,000 sites

AThe Pridwin

Relevancy: 78% KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
3.0
29+ reviews
from 1 sources
TripAdvisor
3.0
29+ reviews
  • a bit on the older side, but the room was bright more on TripAdvisor
  • we were pretty skeptical about it, but we really wanted to stay in a room with kitchenettes more on TripAdvisor

Estimated Price: From $169

The Pridwin
P.O. Box 2009
Crescent Beach, Shelter Island, NY 11965

BRam's Head Inn

Relevancy: 69% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
3.5
6+ reviews
from 3 sources
CitySearch
3.5
0+ reviews
Yelp
3.5
3+ reviews
TripAdvisor
3.5
3+ reviews
  • Highlights: restaurant more
  • spent a lot of time relaxing and reading on the expansive front lawn with its great water view more on TripAdvisor
  • relaxing and reading on the expansive front lawn with its great water view more on TripAdvisor

Estimated Price: From $237

Ram's Head Inn
108 Rams Island Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11965

CPridwin

Relevancy: 68% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
2.5
2+ reviews
from 1 sources
Fodor's
2.5
2+ reviews
  • Highlights: kitchen, refrigerator, bicycle rental… more
  • ... the Pridwin several times now and I'm impressed with the value as compared with other Shelter Island places, especially if you go for the plan that includes dinner. It's waterfront and the pool... more on Fodor's
  • Overview The rambling, old-timey, family-friendly resort is on Crescent Beach. In summer, meals ... more on Fodor's
Pridwin
Shore Rd.
Shelter Island, NY, 11964

DPridwin Hotel & Cottages

Relevancy: 67% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
4.5
2+ reviews
from 1 sources
Yahoo! Travel
4.5
2+ reviews
  • Highlights: game room, kitchen, refrigerator, bic… more
  • we stayed at was lovely and the area of the hotel is both relaxing and rejuvenating more on Yahoo! Travel
  • pridwin hotel a couple of weeks ago and I loved every minute of my stay there more on Yahoo! Travel
Pridwin Hotel & Cottages
Crescent Beach
Shore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

ERam's Head Inn

Relevancy: 66% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

  • Highlights: restaurant more
  • Overview At this 1929 colonial-style inn, Adirondack chairs are scattered across lawns sloping down to Coecles Harbor. The secluded spot ... more on Fodor's
Ram's Head Inn
Ram Island Dr.
Shelter Island, NY, 11965

FSunset Beach

Relevancy: 66% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
3.5
8+ reviews
from 2 sources
CitySearch
3.5
0+ reviews
Tablet Hotels
14.5
8+ reviews
  • Highlights: kitchen, kitchen, restaurant more
  • service at the restaurant is very slow and unattentive. more on Tablet Hotels
  • I love the vibe of sunset beach. more on Tablet Hotels

Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach
35 Shore Rd.
Shelter Island, NY, 11965

GFour West Neck

Relevancy: 65% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
3.0
1+ reviews
from 1 sources
TripAdvisor
3.0
1+ reviews
  • was a nice continental breakfast served everymorning and a nice sunny deck to enjoy it more on TripAdvisor
  • it smells like smoke! the owners stay downstairs and there is a living room, kitchen, two bedrooms and a bathroom upstairs more on TripAdvisor

Estimated Price: From $200

Four West Neck
4 West Neck Road
Shelter Island, NY

HCandlelite Inn

Relevancy: 65% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
3.0
2+ reviews
from 1 sources
TripAdvisor
3.0
2+ reviews
  • ... the private back cottage for our anniversary last October. Upon ariving (Friday) we walked in to a hair salon (main floor of the B & B) and were given a key to the back cottage. The room was ni... more on TripAdvisor
  • ... and I arrived at the Candlelight Inn on a Sunday afternoon in June 06 .The owners were not in but we found a "welcome" letter taped to the door.The portion of the letter that listed the contine... more on TripAdvisor
Candlelite Inn
Route 114 South
Shelter Island, NY

IShelter Island Hideaway

Relevancy: 64% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
5.0
1+ reviews
from 1 sources
Yelp
5.0
1+ reviews
  • Your search for paradise has ended", July 14, 2008 more on Yelp
Shelter Island Hideaway
1 Brander Parkway
Shelter Island,NY,11964

JCandle Lite Inn & Guest House

Relevancy: 64% MAY NOT BE GOOD FOR KID FRIENDLY

Average Rating
4.5
1+ reviews
from 2 sources
CitySearch
3.5
0+ reviews
Yahoo! Travel
5.0
1+ reviews
  • ... Beautiful old Home, great grounds, amazing breakfast, Carol and Callie were a complete delight to wake up and have breakfast with, friendly and accommodating. ... more on Yahoo! Travel
Candle Lite Inn & Guest House
3 S Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964