Shelter Island Heights Hotels - Reviews of Hotels in Shelter Island Heights NY
47 accommodations found from 5,000 sites
ASunset Beach
| Average Rating |
3.5
|
35+ reviews from 4 sources |
|---|---|---|
| TripAdvisor | 3.5 |
25+ reviews |
| Yahoo! Travel | 5.0 |
1+ reviews |
| TravelPost.com | 3.0 |
1+ reviews |
- Highlights: room service, maid service, restauran… more
- modern - bright colors and white on white. Linens are soft and duvet is thick and white more on TripAdvisor
- busy city life every once in a while. Sunset beach is the perfect site for such a getaway more on TripAdvisor
Estimated Price: From $320
Sunset Beach
35 Shore RdShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
BChequit Inn
| Average Rating |
3.5
|
9+ reviews from 2 sources |
|---|---|---|
| Yelp | 4.0 |
3+ reviews |
| TripAdvisor | 3.0 |
6+ reviews |
- Highlights: room service, maid service, restauran… more
- had a very pleasant stay at the chequit last summer while recovering from back surgery more on TripAdvisor
- my room was compact (read tiny! ) but comfortable and had a private bathroom more on TripAdvisor
Estimated Price: From $300
Chequit Inn
23 Grand AveShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
CStearns Point House
| Average Rating |
3.5
|
2+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| TripAdvisor | 3.5 |
2+ reviews |
- No luxury here so overall we found the approx $180/night we paid to be excessive, but it may be ok for the location more on TripAdvisor
- close to crescent beach (5 minute walk) where a nice freanch beach restaurant is located and a hotel more on TripAdvisor
Stearns Point House
7 Stearns Point RoadPO Box 648, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
DOlde Country Inn
| Average Rating |
4.0
|
2+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| TripAdvisor | 4.0 |
2+ reviews |
- Highlights: restaurant more
- ... Inn on Shelter Island, NY (east end of Long Island)is the absolutely the best. This is the third time we've stayed here, and I can't speak highly enough of the experience. Beautiful rooms in th... more on TripAdvisor
- Overview Privacy and romance are yours at this Victorian inn on a country lane. Rooms are named after their color ... more on Fodor's
Estimated Price: From $170
Olde Country Inn
11 Stearns Point RoadShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
EDering Harbor Inn
| Average Rating |
4.5
|
1+ reviews from 2 sources |
|---|---|---|
| CitySearch | 3.5 |
0+ reviews |
| Yahoo! Travel | 5.0 |
1+ reviews |
- Highlights: maid service, restaurant, non-smoking… more
- Location: Shelter Island, New York (0.4 miles from Shelter Island Heights)
- Overview Description :Lodge style, 7-acre site directly on Dering Harbor - Overlooking Dering Harbor. more on ProfessionalTravelGuide.com
- ... view like the one at Dering Harbor, you don't need anything else. But wait, there's more: tennis courts, basketball net, badmiton nets, picnic area, and a pool too! Don't go for the rooms, whic... more on Yahoo! Travel
Estimated Price: From $170
Dering Harbor Inn
13 Winthrop RdShelter Island, NY 11964
FHouse on Chase Creek
- husband and I enjoyed chatting with him! overall, nice stay! more on TripAdvisor
- air conditioned room was decorated with antiques and the king sized bed extremely comfortable more on TripAdvisor
Estimated Price: From $147
House on Chase Creek
3 Locust Ave.Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
GBelle Crest House
- Highlights: internet access, high speed internet … more
- Overview Built in the 1920s, the cozy inn decorated with period antiques and personal artifacts remains family-owned ... more on Fodor's
- Overview Built in the 1920s, the cozy inn decorated with period antiques and personal artifacts remains family-owned ... more on Fodor's
Belle Crest House
163 N Ferry RdShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
HDering Harbor Inn
| Average Rating |
4.5
|
1+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| Fodor's | 4.5 |
1+ reviews |
- Highlights: pool, restaurant, vcr player, kitchen… more
- suites are spotless and the view from the rooms is breathtaking more on Fodor's
- ... and the view from the rooms is breathtaking... The sunsets are just beautiful. Everything is close by but you feel as if you are all alone the pool ... more on Fodor's
Dering Harbor Inn
13 Winthrop Rd.Shelter Island Heights, NY, 11965
IVictorian Lady
| Average Rating |
4.5
|
14+ reviews from 4 sources |
|---|---|---|
| CitySearch | 3.5 |
0+ reviews |
| Yahoo! Travel | 5.0 |
1+ reviews |
| TripAdvisor | 4.5 |
12+ reviews |
- constructive criticism ends here - all other details about our stay were absolutely perfect more on TripAdvisor
- was the second stay for us at the victorican lady and it was absolutely wonderful more on TripAdvisor
Victorian Lady
151 Bay AveGreenport, NY 11944
JHarborfront Inn at Greenport
| Average Rating |
4.0
|
25+ reviews from 1 sources |
|---|---|---|
| TripAdvisor | 4.0 |
25+ reviews |
- Highlights: pool, internet access, high speed int… more
- Location: Greenport, New York (1.1 miles from Shelter Island Heights)
- I highly recommend this hotel if you want to stay in the north fork more on TripAdvisor
- great place to stay more on TripAdvisor
Estimated Price: From $284
Harborfront Inn at Greenport
209 Front StGreenport, NY 11944
