Romantic Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York

#1.

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, Long Island, NY 11965

Sunset Beach
3.0
User Rating (2 sources) ×
  • My friend twisted my arm and made me visit Shelter Island and she dictated that we were staying at Sunset B... more on TripAdvisor
  • Overview Between the N.& S. fork, seasonal hotel on Shelter Island. more on iloveny.com
 

See_details_btn

#2.

Olde Country Inn

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island, Long Island, New York

Olde Country Inn
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • Overview This charming Victorian inn, originally built circa 1886, is located on beautiful Shelter Is... more on BedAndBreakfast.com
  • Food was uninspirering & staff was overwhelmed. Would not go back. more on TripAdvisor
 

See_details_btn

#3.

Chequit Inn

23 Grand Ave., Shelter Island, Long Island, New York

Chequit Inn
3.0
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • Overview Is Chequit Inn a hot-rod or a jalopy? Read on. Summarizing more than seven ideas and opinions from numerous...
  • It was clean and so nicely decorated! more on TripAdvisor
 

See_details_btn

#4.

Ram's Head Inn

Ram's Island Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY

Ram's Head Inn
 

See_details_btn

#5.

Sunset Beach

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, Ne 11965

Sunset Beach
3.5
User Rating (2 sources) ×
  • Tablet Hotels
  • CitySearch
  • Hotelier Andr� Balazs transformed an old motel into a sophisticated, retro jewel overlooking Shelter... more on TravelAndLeisure.com
  • The fridge and sink were so rusty and moldy, they should seal it off as a hazardous area. more on Tablet Hotels
 

#6.

The Greenporter Hotel and Spa

326 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944

The Greenporter Hotel and Spa
3.5
User Rating (3 sources) ×
  • Rooms are clean , but dark, small, cold linoleum floors, with no counter space, or closets. more on CitySearch
  • My wife and I were looking for a hotel that would allow us to park our car and walk to restaurants and bars... more on igougo
 

#7.

Belle Crest House

163 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Belle Crest House
3.5
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • CitySearch
 

See_details_btn

#8.

House On Chase Creek

3 Locust Ave, Shelter Isle HTS, NY 11965

House On Chase Creek
3.5
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • CitySearch
 

See_details_btn

#9.

Dering Harbor Inn

13 Winthrop Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965, United States

Dering Harbor Inn
4.5
User Rating (2 sources) ×
  • Overview Description :Lodge style, 7-acre site directly on Dering Harbor - Overlooking Dering Harbor. more on ProfessionalTravelGuide.com
  • With a view like the one at Dering Harbor, you don't need anything else. more on Yahoo! Travel
 

See_details_btn

#10.

Olde Country Inn

11 Stearns Point Rd Shelter Isle Hts, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, USA

Olde Country Inn
3.5
User Rating (1 sources) ×
  • CitySearch
  • Overview Circa 1886. Situated on Shelter Island between North and South Forks of Long Island, New York, Olde Country Inn was built in 1886 and has been renovated for comfort. The old English d�cor and Victorian ... more on ILoveInns.com
 

See_details_btn

Shelter Island Heights Lodging

Shelter Island Heights Things To Do

New York Resources

© 2006 - 2012 Uptake Networks, Inc.

Uptake

Get the best tips and advice by discovering which of your friends have been to Shelter Island Heights, and also reach our helpful and experienced Uptake travel community. Sign in!

×
Uptake

Did you know that your Internet Explorer is out of date?


To get the best possible experience using our website we recommend that you upgrade to a newer version.

Close