Sunset Beach - Shelter Island Heights Hotel

  • Address: 35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
  • Phone: 6317492001
  • Website:www.sunsetbeachli.com
Average Rating
3.5
35+ reviews
from 4 sources
Yelp
4.0
8+ reviews
TripAdvisor
3.5
25+ reviews
TravelPost.com
3.0
1+ reviews
Yahoo! Travel
5.0
1+ reviews

Estimated Price: From $320

Sunset Beach
35 Shore Rd
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Sunset Beach Details

We Recommend Sunset Beach Because

  • "modern - bright colors and white on white. Linens are soft and duvet is thick and white" more on TripAdvisor
  • "stumbled upon while exploring and have sent so many people there that just love it" more on Yahoo! Travel
  • "are in st tropez on a hot summer weekend with the beautiful people, ridiculous." more on Yelp
  • "absolutely loved it! living and working in new york city is very exciting, but it is important to get away from the busy city" more on TripAdvisor
  • "- great food and drinks - the sunsets are great and the fact that the upper level of seating is atopped by trees make this a gre" more on Yelp

Full Amenity List

  • Kitchenette
  • television
  • cable television
  • minibar
  • maid service
  • fire alarm
  • telephone
  • balcony/lanai/terrace
  • air conditioning
  • Wireless internet access
  • Cable/satellite televsion
  • non-smoking
  • Lounge/bar
  • room service
  • ATM/banking
  • Coffee/Tea maker
  • Babysitting
  • On-Site parking
  • Restaurant
  • Free parking
  • bicycle rentals
  • complimentary coffee in lobby
  • baby sitting
  • kitchen
  • atm/cash machine

Reviews From Across The Web read all

5.0
incredible place

(09/23/05)

... Sunset beach is the ultimate location on long island to vacation. We stumbled upon while exploring and have sent so many people there that just love it. It's also great because they will welcome your pet !!! The food is great and the ... A Yahoo! User, a user of Yahoo! Travel. Read full review on Yahoo! Travel

Tripadvisorlogo-11383-0
5.0
highly recommended

(Oct 30, 2007)

... New York city and decided to take a break out in Shelter Island. Sunset Beach was perfect - although only a short visit, the staff were very friendly and welcoming. The room itself was very spacious, well equipped and spotlessly clean. ... annyaDublin, a user of Tripadvisor. Read full review on TripAdvisor

3.0
extremely mediocre

(Jul 14, 07)

... the big long black hair in my sink (my wife and I have light hair) 2. the missing handle on my screen door which wouldn't stay on track after you managed to get it open, and the hole in the screen 3. the air conditioner which cycled ... queritas, a user of Travelpost. Read full review on TravelPost.com

5.0
Anna S. 's review

... Sunset Beach out on Shelter Island. It is definitely the place to hang and catch a sunset while snuggling with your hot honey on the ... a user of yelp.com. Read full review on Yelp

Tripadvisorlogo-11383-0
5.0
Fabulous treasure in Shelter Island

(Jul 5, 2007)

... stay at Sunset Beach, Long Island. We had originally booked for 4 nights at the beginning of June but loved it so much we ended up staying an extra night. The room was spacious, spotless, and very comfortable with a sizeable private ... NewYorkMclachlan, a user of Tripadvisor. Read full review on TripAdvisor

Miscellaneous

  • Number Of Floors: 2
  • Number Of Rooms: 20

Other Web Resources

  • Read more about Sunset Beach on Yahoo! Travel
  • www.sunsetbeachli.com

Plan a trip

Frequent Flier Miles & Points Cash Converter

Loyalty match